CDL: Assessing political bias in library collections (response 3)

From: John P Abbott <abbottjp_at_iplm3.appstate.edu>
Date: Sun, 28 Jan 2007 07:52:35 -0500
To: COLLDV-L_at_usc.edu
Original posting is in the archives:

http://www.infomotions.com/serials/colldv-
l/archive/2007/200701/0017.html

==#3==
Hello,

Growing weary of casual and not so casual comments from conservatives 
regarding our large periodicals collection at the University of 
Washington 
(Seattle) and its alleged leftist orientation, I decided to see if it 
was 
true (which, frankly, I suspected it was).  Much to my surprise, after 
going through most of the currently received paper copy subscriptions 
to 
political magazines, research journals, quarterlies, etc., I 
discovered 
that, roughly speaking, "Conservative" and "Liberal" journals were 
within 
two or three titles of each other, with liberal titles outnumbering 
conservative titles---hardly a gross imbalance.

I've forgotten the total number of titles reviewed, but somewhere in 
the 
neighborhood of 25 or 30 titles of publications self-described as 
"Conservative" or "Liberal."  These journals are only a subset of a 
much 
larger, diverse collection, ranging from Communist journals to the 
Libertarian Party official publication, etc.

I looked again at this balance question a couple of years ago and 
found 
that a slight shift had occured with Conservative print titles 
outnumbering the Liberal publications by two.

We originally pulled all of this info together in a web page designed 
to 
help students find different perspectives on political issues.  The 
page 
is called, rather unoriginally, "Opposing Views."  Of course, it 
includes 
a large number of political web sites too, which now far outweigh the 
periodical titles we still receive in paper.  And the aggragated 
journals 
databases also open up a universe of various politically oriented 
sources.

Our web page is again in need of updating, but it is still useful in 
academic reference work.

Glenda Pearson
Suzzallo Allen Library
University of Washington
Seattle, Washington 98195
Received on Sun Jan 28 2007 - 06:53:54 EST