> Er, maybe I am mistaking Karen's point, but I think she was getting at
> that if this was on a blog, rather than a professional mailing list,
> the outside world be able to weigh in on how Weinberger was being
> written off as a 'misinterpretation of Aristotle' or whatever.
>
> Not that she wants to follow along in Bloglines.
>
> But what do I know?
> -Ross.
Oh, now, Ross, don't spoil my fun! ;-)
The original quote was, "The thing is that I suspect Weinberger has fallen
prey to a naïve reading of Aristotle."
Wherever you weigh in on the miscellaneous/uber-order debate, suggesting
that Weinberger, with his PhD in philosophy and the rest of his track
record, somehow doesn't "get" Aristotle, reflects on the unproductive
solipsism and haul-up-the-bridge idea-resistance of some discussion on this
list.
K.G. Schneider
kgs_at_freerangelibrarian.com
Received on Wed Jun 06 2007 - 06:58:45 EDT