Re: coyle/hillman article from dlib [mods]

From: Simon Spero <ses_at_nyob>
Date: Thu, 18 Jan 2007 16:08:44 -0800
To: NGC4LIB_at_listserv.nd.edu
On Jan 18, 2007, at 10:13 AM, kcoyle_at_kcoyle.net wrote:

> ***kc: and that DC documentation is a just a few pages in length and
> uses a fairly general vocabulary. AACR2 is hundreds of pages, and we
> know that the MARC format fills a 3-4" binder. Note that the
> document with two chapters of RDA (6 and 7) is 120 pages in length.
> The barriers to using library standards are enormous.***

Forget the barriers  - the library standards are enormous!
Out of curiousity, does anybody happen to know  how much a complete
set of cataloging documentation weighs (say AACR2, MARC Bibliographic
+ Concise, LCSH, LCC,  plus current interpretations etc.)?

You are being a bit harsh on the RDA here: chapters 6 and 7 don't
start till page seven, so there are only  114 pages that count.  Of
course, there are 37  examples that are currently missing...

RDA is Really the Damn AACR, not a Revolution in Descriptive Affairs

> kc - in SeaTac airport (No, the wi-fi isn't free)

Actually, they pass DNS requests, but that's cheating.  Definitely
free wireless in the UW Bookstore Cafe

Simon
Received on Thu Jan 18 2007 - 18:11:06 EST